Pox and the City

The last essay in the fifth chapter of Dougherty’s and Nawrotzki’s book, Writing History in the Digital Age, describes the challenges four collaborators had to face when they tried to create a history game.

Pox and the City: Edinburgh is a browser-based educational game about the application of Dr. Edward Jenner’s smallpox vaccine in 19th century Edinburgh, Scotland.

During its early development stages, the four main contributors Laura Zucconi, Ethan Watrall, Hannah Ueno and Lisa Rosner found out that creating a game was not as easy as they thought, since their ideas were not always practical. Although all of them had some background in programming and designing, with some added knowledge as historians and anthropologists, it was not as straightforward to combine all of that into a successful game. Over time, it became clear to the developers that it was impossible to create a history game in a similar manner to the ’traditional’ creation process in history, i.e. by an isolated individual locked away in a study. Only by working together and combining their different expertise, were they able to overcome the challenges. Eventually, they settled on a number of parameters that they wanted to use as the basis for the game which were then integrated into a valid map of Edinburgh of the time. After all, they wanted to create a game that was not only interesting for different levels of users, but was also able to help these users with different approaches to research.

The essay Pox and the City stresses the importance of collaboration as well as the possibilities of digital representation in history. In this case, they were trying to satisfy not only users of the game, but also historians. Granted, it is impossible to create a perfect solution for everyone, but by structuring the game around their basic parameters, they managed to cover all the important factors and create a useful educational tool at the same time.

Advertisements

About AMK @ Ryerson

In the past, I was the experienced IT admin and troubleshooter, but the new me is going to be a creative analyst for sustainable solutions (maybe!).
This entry was posted in HIS 500 and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Pox and the City

  1. Despite having the intention of historical education, I believe “Pox and the City” will be successful past the educational level. It is evident that the creators conducted research outside of historical facts. The interactive nature of the game, allowing the players to enter establishments of a quaint 19th century city, is reminiscent of the vastly popular fantasy MMORPG Runescape.
    I agree with your point regarding how the creation of the game was the result of the collaboration of different areas of expertise. I think that is something to consider for our classroom project of mapping Ryerson. We may have split into specialized groups but I think it is also necessary to discuss the relevant skills of each member.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s